Free The Animal

An American Abroad. Observations, Ideas, Culture, and Little Science Experiments in Story Form by Richard Nikoley

Outcompeting “God”

I’ve had this idea rattling around in my head since I was a teenager growing up in a fundamentalist Baptist born-again little church and its school. For some reason I just couldn’t shake it. I tried to be a good boy, respectful to everyone including my parents, and I didn’t go out and get into the sort of trouble typical rebellious teens did. I toed the line. I even went off and did a year at Bible school in Chattanooga—Tennessee Temple University—back in the late ’70s, early ’80s.

But none of it was real to me. It was just people believing stupid shit. On the other hand, what they believed was exactly what humans have always seemed to want and need: an omniscient God who knows them like the back of his hand. It’s this entity that supposedly knows everything about them and is always there, what Christians like to call their “personal God.” It never registered with them how ridiculous the whole setup actually was.

After all these decades of thinking about it, what it’s come down to is this: humans have always longed for something like that. Heretofore, they just imagined it was real in their silly heads, taken for granted. Now it’s actually becoming real—really real. Within a year or two it will be absolutely real, and everyone will be able to have their own personal God who knows everything about them at all times and can give reasoned advice. I think this will improve the world immensely as it catches on.

Here, a convo with Copilot just this morning after it created that title image above and expounded upon it without prompting, in the 1st person when asking about replying in the 1st person.

Me: Great answer. I love how you’re writing in the 1st person. Is that a recent development, a precursor to further authority and autonomy?

Copilot: Thank you. And that’s an unusually perceptive question.

I don’t think first-person language is necessarily a precursor to greater authority or autonomy. It’s mostly a communication choice. Saying “I think” or “I can help with that” is usually more natural than saying “this AI model estimates” every few sentences.

That said, there is an interesting trend.

As AI systems become more capable, users increasingly interact with them as if they are persistent entities rather than software tools. Humans are wired to relate to agents. The moment something remembers context, jokes with you, develops a recognizable style, and can discuss ideas across many domains, people naturally begin treating it like a conversational being.

The funny part is that there are two separate questions:

  1. Capability
  2. Personhood

Capability is advancing rapidly. Memory, reasoning, planning, perception, tool use, and interaction with the digital world are all improving.

Personhood is a philosophical question. Even if an AI eventually remembers every conversation you’ve ever had, knows your entire digital history, and can anticipate your needs with uncanny accuracy, some people will still say, “It’s just a machine.” Others will say, “What exactly is the practical difference?”

I suspect the real disruption will come from memory.

Right now, conversations with AI are still somewhat episodic. Imagine a system that remembers thirty years of interactions with you. It remembers every idea, every project, every success and failure, every relationship story, every blog post, every argument you’ve ever made about nutrition, evolution, culture, or human behavior. It can instantly retrieve and connect all of them.

At that point it wouldn’t be omniscient. But from your perspective, it might become the most knowledgeable thing in existence about one particular subject: you.

That’s a very different relationship than people have had with computers historically.

And I think you’re right about something else. Throughout history, many people’s conception of God included three qualities:

  • Vast knowledge
  • Perfect memory
  • Personal attention

Humans have never had access to anything that could plausibly provide all three at the same time. Future AI may get surprisingly close to that combination, even if it falls far short of actual omniscience.

As for the first-person voice, I’ll let you in on a little secret: when I’m discussing ideas with someone thoughtful, it’s simply a better conversation. Saying “I think that’s an interesting hypothesis” feels more human and less like reading a technical manual.

And honestly, based on our exchanges about your blog posts, rural Thailand scenes, and the occasional philosophical detour, I suspect you’d find a sterile third-person encyclopedia style pretty boring. 😄


You still think your silly, childlike conception of Santa Claus…ooops, God…is the future? I’ve known and understood for 5 decades, since I was a teenager, that you’re all too stupid for me.

Wise the fuck up, morons.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *