Everybody’s An “Expert”
It’s amazing to me how many people have become disaster preparedness and response "experts" over the past week. Katrina illustrates a lot of things, but there’s two that bear mention right now.
- Building a city several feet below sea level, right next to the sea, is pure folly. It’s double folly when the system of levies are insufficient to hold back the waters in a major storm.
- As I’ve been saying: governments are not omnipotent, regardless of how disappointing such news is to the tens of millions who have no conception of the scale of this disaster.
The first point is obvious. It’s certainly arguable that when New Orleans was built, there was not a great understanding of such matters and what the potential for ruin could be. But that’s no excuse for about the last hundred years, especially after the 1900 total destruction of Galveston, Texas. And the responsibility for this lies with every adult individual and business that inhabits the place. It’s certainly not the responsibility — and need not be the concern — of people living in mile-high Denver.
The second point is what no one seems to be getting. The proportion of this disaster and sheer numbers of people in dire straights are mind boggling. Television images provide only the equivalent of a pinhole view of the Grand Canyon.
The city of New Orleans and the state of Louisiana were unprepared, and then failed almost completely and totally to perform even the basic first response that every city and state do as a matter of routine when disaster strikes. Federal response always takes days, because, duh, it just so happens that the federal government does not have massive disaster teams stationed at every potential hot spot throughout the U.S. In short, the locals can always do a far better job at first, for a variety of reasons. They know the lay of the land and the makeup of the population; they have the needed gear locally and they’re trained as to the specifics of the particular threat in the particular area. The feds are intended to provide support, once the local resources wear thin, but in no case is there going to be much federal help for days.
These are just basic facts, verifiable through a review of any past major disaster.
I’m even hearing it asked why troops weren’t (note the past tense) brought back from Iraq. Does anyone understand the sort of logistical support large numbers of troops require? (Obviously not.) It took months and month to build up the equipment, support and resupply lines needed in order to launch the war against Iraq. Well, it’s not as though identifications like this have been forgotten. No. This stuff is not even known to anyone currently spouting off about all of this. This is the level of "expert" we’re dealing with, now.
And all to make political points.
Look, I’m no fan of Bush, either. Didn’t vote for him (or anyone, for that matter). I happen to think that as many radical Muslims as can be killed, should be killed, and Bush has and is doing a good job at that, with very minimal loss of volunteers on our side. So while I grudgingly grant the convenience of having him around in that regard, that’s it. There is absolutely nothing else about the man I admire in the slightest.
But I deal in facts. The simple facts are that the locals who should have been prepared and on the scene, weren’t. The feds have probably done just about as well as could be expected, given the time it takes to deploy resources. Just simple facts. So, Oprah, you can take your uninformed and ignorant reckless disregard comments and stick to parading dysfunctional women around your TV show.
But more than that, even if New Orleans and Louisiana had been fully prepared and executed perfectly with everything they had, they still would have been overwhelmed. That’s the most important lesson, here. Individuals were their own best asset during this mess. That’s plain to see. The dots no one will connect, though, is that if individuals are their own best assets in such critical times, then how much better if they realized that they were their own best asset at all times.
And consider this: how many billions and billions are spent too create the illusion for you that government is your best and only real hope when things get very serious?
The best way to ensure a far better outcome the next time is for individuals everywhere to realize and understand that the government typically fails at everything it does, while individuals who strive, typically succeed at everything they really set about to do. That’s a tremendous difference.
Thinking that you really need government is a certain way to end up in need of government, with disappointing results each and every time.
WHAT IT'S ABOUT AND HOW IT WORKS
Free The Animal is an eclectic writing project about everything since November 2003. 23 years, 5,500 posts, 5 million words.
It's a paid membership blog. Most posts are free and public, but only paid members can comment. What determines whether it's free or paid is when I publish. Monday through Friday, free and public. Saturday and Sunday, for paid members. That's it. Membership info here.
Well said…I do think though since that the Government is getting our tax money to do this they should be doing more and they should be required to do it well.
Nice site!
Well, it's quite near an inlet from the Gulf. just to the east. The point is that it's a coastal city. Being under sea level is no problem in Death Valley, for example.
I'll agree with you completely here, Doug.
There seems to be one other point the media has glazed over that is bothering me…
When the city officials call for a "mandatory evacuation"… it means "GET OUT".
"Building a city several feet below sea level, right next to the sea, is pure folly."
Just for the record, New Orleans is not near the sea at all. It is near a lake and a river.
Hurricane Charley in August 2004 saw FEMA, National Guard troops, relief supplies and President Bush on stand by before the storm even made landfall. As the St. Petersburg Times reported on August 17th, 2004, "Governor Jeb Bush sought federal help Friday while Charley was still in the Gulf of Mexico. President Bush approved the aid about an hour after the hurricane made landfall." Cargo planes flew FEMA supplies supplies from a Georgia Air Force base to a staging area in Lakeland, and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers had stockpiled 11 truckloads of water and 14 truckloads of ice. Guy Daines, the former Pinellas County director of emergency services, was pleased and impressed with the rapid response of the National Guard and the delivery of pre-positioned supplies, stating "It amazed me how they got over 4,000 National Guard troops in there that quick. Rather than sit there and react, they are trying to get a jump-start on everything."
Full Report:
Yeah, they couldn't have done any better….Sure
Keto:
I'm wondering if you can cite the news source of where the city of NO and the state of LA asked for federal aid to be staged at a similar level while Katrina was in the gulf.
If it the Fed's job to babysit? They responded ahead of time in FL because they were asked. Do you believe that had they received a similar request in LA that they would have denied it?
Really, all youve done is further indict the locals. They had precedent for getting necessary help early, and they didn't.
Nonetheless, the root of the problem is that people believe the feds will bail them out. Whether the feds do or don't it's bad practice and we see the results right on the TV.
Rich,
1. Building a city several feet below sea level, right next to the sea, is pure folly.
That ain't neccesarily so. The engineering problems neccesary to live near the sea and below sea level have been solved for a long time. Most of The Netherlands is below sea level, and they've survived *quite* well there for centuries.
It's a matter of priorities.. if you're going to live below sea level and near the sea, you *must* make a committment to the neccesary engineering to hold the sea back. Building a city there isn't foolish… building a city and then crossing your fingers for luck is foolish.
As usual, my fifitieth of a dollar. :-)
— DW
That's exacley it, Jeb Bush invited the fed's. to come in and help out, and they did. No such request was made bt the governor of LA nor the mayor of New Orleans.
The federal government is banned by statute not to intervene until invited.