Auto “Insurance” Run Like Medical “Insurance”

For many, many years I’ve said that people are NOT talking about medical or health “insurance,” but rather a bumper-to-bumper full maintenance plan. My longtime friend, Kyle Bennett, illustrates how it would go if people were as stupid and ignorant about automobile maintenance and insurance as they are about so-called health insurance.

~~~

If you handled your car expenses the way most people handle health “insurance”….

You’d get a plan paid for by your employer that covers gas, oil changes, new tires, maintenance and even washing and detailing. Accidents too, by the way. You would have to go to the car dealer for anything, including filling the gas tank, and there would only be a handful of them in town. Maybe only one or none in some small towns. You’d have to make an appointment for gas or a tune-up, and even so you’d spend most of the day in the waiting room.

If you don’t have coverage and had to pay for these things yourself, you’d pay a lot. Gas would be $75 a gallon, an oil change would cost $500 (Jiffy Lube would be banned). If you needed a tune-up, it would have to be an in-patient procedure requiring you to leave your car for several days. Maybe two weeks. You’d not only have to pay for the service itself, parts, and the mechanic who does it, totalling $8500, but you’d have to pay for a specialist in turning the engine on and off, a surcharge for the tools and diagnostic computer, and, of course, a fee for keeping the car all those days ($900/day).

But, so long as you had a job, all those things would be covered for only a $300 deduction per paycheck. It wouldn’t matter if your car was brand new and never breaks down, or an old clunker that barely gets you to work. Of course, if you switched jobs, you would lose your coverage, and buying a new policy would be very expensive since your car might have pre-existing conditions. Or, you could carry over the premium for only an additional $600/month.

You’d also have to spend half your life hearing arguments from the people who created that system that it is completely unfair and too expensive, so we should go to a single-payer system and have the government cover everything. After that happens, they’d eventually decide, for efficiency purposes, that everybody should drive the same car, produced by the government (think Yugo). If you’re lucky, there will only be a three-year waiting list for them.

Of course, the people advocating that you just pay for these things yourself, except for major accidents, would be crazy. Nobody could afford to do that.

~~~

The whole thing is a direct cause of generations of financial and economic illiteracy and the general dumbing down of America, such that it’s ripe for political and big-corp exploitation at every turn.

…And so it’s well deserved, because everyone should always get exactly what they deserve.


WHAT IT'S ABOUT AND HOW IT WORKS

Free The Animal is an eclectic writing project about everything since November 2003. 23 years, 5,500 posts, 5 million words.

It's a paid membership blog. Most posts are free and public, but only paid members can comment. What determines whether it's free or paid is when I publish. Monday through Friday, free and public. Saturday and Sunday, for paid members. That's it. Membership info here.

6 Comments

  1. Brad on August 13, 2013 at 15:52

    You forgot to mention that the members of congress who mandated such a program would of course be exempt from driving a “Yugo”. They would likely be driving Hummers and their $8,000 per month gas bill would be covered as well as all their maintenance costs.



  2. JP on August 13, 2013 at 19:13

    Lasik is a good example of medicine outside of the gov’t/insurance system. It’s actually gotten cheaper as free market forces have run their course.



  3. Marc on August 14, 2013 at 14:25

    Thats fucking brilliant.
    thank you Kyle.

    Marc



  4. Kayumochi on August 16, 2013 at 13:09

    Don’t forget the million dollar medical bill some cancer patients are left with and are forced to declare bankruptcy even though they have jobs and health insurance … the system is designed to suck every last dollar away and leave nothing.



  5. Kayumochi on August 16, 2013 at 13:22

    Thing about Lasik, and I researched this because my wife in interested, is that now that every hack eye clinic performs it, the bar has been lowered: years ago those with certain conditions were advised not to have the surgery. Not now. Come one, come all and get Lasik now for the cheap price of $XXXX per eye. Sadly many Lasik patients will have to live with the devastating results. My wife won’t be getting the surgery.



  6. Michael Ejercito on September 24, 2013 at 07:11

    One other important difference is that pre-existing conditions have never been a barrier to auto insurance. Someone with multiple pre-existing drunk driving convictions can nevertheless get auto insurance. But pre-existing conditions have been a barrier to health insurance.