The Whole Dramatic Story: Neighbor Files Civil Harassment Restraining Order Against Me

IMG_0405

It all began one late afternoon two months ago, February 12, 2017. While we have a doggie door and fenced area in back, they’re dogs. Periodically they must absolutely see if the rest of the yard checks out…not to mention the added necessity of marking a perimeter.

Those pungent aromas don’t last forever, you know. They require regular and continued maintenance.

So I let them down in front sometimes, the three little rat terriers. Because there are two large dogs (about 70 lbs each) across the cul-de-sac, mine often run across, barking—because the others have no right to exist, according to dog brain. Early on, when we began living here full-time last May, mine would encroach on their property, sometimes. But I had ended that some time ago (whereas, theirs still venture into our yard from time-to-time—which is fine with me). In this instance, I was unaware that one or both of their dogs were out. One of them, Moo, the female, ran out in a flash, picked out one of mine, Nuke, and chased her 30 feet across the cul-de-sac, then clamped down hard when she caught her.

IMG_0308

My 11-yr-old girl Nanuka (“Nuke”)

Nuke was shaken up. Choncho, the Alpha, wasn’t much bothered, but junior male Scout was incensed beyond barks. He came up to the loft area, jumped up on the backrest of the sofa where he can see out across to where those dogs live and gave them a non-stop scolding for two hours or more. Outraged.

I saw the whole thing from the deck and while setting off to run down the stairs, yelled “Hey!” at the top of my lungs; Moo ceased the attack. There’s no certain way of knowing if she’d have pursued further, otherwise.

Nuke’s puncture bite did not appear to be super-serious or anything, so no need for emergency care. However, the next morning she was super sore, wouldn’t walk down the stairs (she normally bounds down 2-3 steps at a time), was reluctant to walk and when she did, did so obliquely, favoring one leg.

So I took her to the vet. Muscular-skeletal trauma. She got a few-day course of an anti-inflammatory, and it helped. $78. After a day, she began licking at it incessantly, so I called the vet who said to bring her on in. She shaved the wound area and gave a 7-day course of antibiotic. She advised against dressing or suturing the rather deep hole Nuke had created via 27/7 licking. First, it would require anesthetizing. Beyond that, she’d need to wear the collar and we’d have to clean the wound and watch it carefully for signs of infection. She was already keeping it “clean” by licking, so infection was unlikely to gain a foothold. Smart country vet. $112 total for the two visits and both meds.

Props to Arnold Pet Clinic.

That day, I reported the incident to the Calaveras County Animal Services. While there is no leash law in the county, there is a standard of reasonable control. Since the incident took place in the street, and neither of us was immediately present, we’re both at fault on that score. However, since there was a puncture, the neighbors were obliged to show proof of a rabies vaccine and could not, so Moo was taken away for an eight-day quarantine at their expense, according to Animal Services.

It’s important to note at this juncture that not once did the neighbors—a 24-yr-young woman and a 23-yr-young man—contact me to express any regret, inquire about Nuke’s well-being, offer to pay the vet bill, or offer any suggestions or signal any willingness to explore ways to minimize the risk of this, or worse, happening again.

And this is unsurprising. When we moved in permanently last May, Beatrice once saw her outside with the two dogs and went over along with our dogs to introduce herself and chat. After noticing for a while, I went over as well. The conversation was cordial enough and the dogs—under adult supervision—got along fine, typical dog banter. Curiously, however, her boyfriend sat up on their roof getting a sunbath or something and made no effort to be a little neighborly.

I spoke cordially with her a second time out front, sometime later. Then noticed odd things, like when one afternoon I was driving home and the both of them and the two dogs were out walking. I rolled down the passenger-side window and offered a greeting, “Hi folks. Hi Moo. Hi Stub.”

Nothing and in fact, he noticeably turned away.

And then there were the several incidents I witnessed first hand from the deck where, as he was coming from or going to work and the dogs were out, they’d run up barking as small dogs typically do. Rather than handle it in a common mature and adult manner by either laughing at the dogs or bending down to befriend them, he would run and stomp and kick at them.

So, all of this combined, and since they are renters (she and her father are on the lease, the boyfriend is not), I decided to inform the landlord of my wishes that he evict them and get new tenants with no dogs, or small dogs, since to the extent they are uncooperative, I have no means of minimizing risk short of leaving my dogs locked up all the time.

I mailed the landlord, outlining my concerns and wishes, attaching a copy of the report to Animal Services, the initial vet bill, and a picture of Nuke’s wound. After mailing it, I left a copy of all the foregoing outside on their truck.

Not long thereafter as I’m sitting out on my deck, she comes stomping up the stairs and the fist entitled screeching out of her is “are you seriously going to try to get us kicked out?” The conversation went downhill from there, with me treating her in kind and worse, being just as awful as I could be.

Once she left, I headed down to the market for a couple of things and when I returned, I went over and knocked on her door; she came out on the patio. Since I was at her place, I refrained from calling her any awful names, but I relayed to her that I’d forgotten to mention earlier that I’d seen her boyfriend stomp and kick at my dogs.

The next morning, I get an absolutely irate and unprofessional call from a deputy sheriff. He’d spoken with my neighbors and by damn I had better not “take matters into my own hands” and “I need to go through proper channels and due process.” I told him he had no fucking idea what he was talking about and that he ought to get off his ass, drive up here, and conduct a proper police investigation. “I don’t need to come up there. What you need to do…”

“I don’t need to to do fuck all. Click!”

An hour or so later, I call the sheriff, informed them that I had had an abrupt conversation with one of their deputies, and could they send a different deputy to my house to discuss it? A couple of hours later, I got a call from another deputy. We engaged in a cordial conversation where I explained the whole matter and got an Oh, ah.

And then nothing happens. In a week or so, I got a call from her landlord and we had a cordial conversation. Said he’d never seen the dogs, nor met the boyfriend. He also informed me that her father had co-signed the lease. He ended by saying he’ll contact them to see what could be done and contact me in a week’s time, which he did.

The second conversation was cordial as well, but nothing was accomplished. I reiterated my offer from the first conversation: that I would be willing to get with her or both of them to socialize all the dogs from time-to-time, under supervised conditions. I’ll supply the duck jerky treats, too. Nothing came of that either.

By now, it’s 2-3 weeks since the event. Fast forward 3-4 weeks and on a Thursday, March 30—a full six weeks since any contact whatsoever with the neighbor on February 13, I get a knock at the door and it’s a deputy sheriff. He has papers.

He’s there to personally serve me notice of a hearing in the Calaveras County Superior Court in San Andreas, on April 13, in the matter of my neighbor’s petition for a civil harassment restraining order. Her ex parte petition for a TRO (temporary restraining order) was denied on the basis that the evidence presented was not sufficient to merit it and that since it involved a dog complaint it should go through Animal Services for proper disposition.

Now I’m really pissed. See, when I’d spoken with the landlord a few weeks prior, he gave zero indication this was in the pipeline, so either his tenant wasn’t being forthright with him, or he was being disingenuous to me.

He promptly got a call, and I was surely at my most awful with him. Hung up on him before he got a chance to respond. He called back after a few minutes. I’d cooled down substantially. He said he’d call her father and see what was up. He called back Saturday night—a bit inebriated, I believe—to tell me he’d spoken to his attorney, has no liability, it’s between us and promptly hung up.

The petition filed by my neighbor is a piece of silly work, in my opinion. It’s essentially a plea that the government restrains me from calling her or her boyfriend bad names, not write anything about them on the internet, not contact her landlord, not call or email, and remain greater than 20 yards from either of them, their house, their truck, and their two dogs. Amusingly, if you were to step out the 20 yards out onto the street, I’d violate the order every time I left or came home.

It would also require me to surrender my guns and ammo for safekeeping, either to a licensed gun dealer or law enforcement for the duration of the order.

To support all of this was a narrative explaining the events of the evening of February 13. But in nowhere or case was she able to show any threat to her, et al, neither any pattern of harassment, stalking, obsessive behavior towards her, et al. She also attached 20-something pages of Facebook and blog posts variously labeled things like “sexist, anti-social, anti-police,” and so on.

My response to the petition largely consists of the foregoing, only with less style and more word economy.

The hearing took place yesterday morning, April 13. It was presided over by Judge Timothy S. Healy, Calaveras County Superior Court. Though one can never predict an outcome in court, I was pretty confident going in how things would roll, having been involved in many legal matters over 20 years, in connection with a company I owned. I’m also a bit better off than your average bloke with his Juris Doctorate from the Xfinity TV School of Law. And, I’m fortunate to have consulted with my cousin, who’s been a practicing attorney in complex business litigation in Los Angeles since the late 1980s.

Judge Healy opened the session by explaining that of the various kinds of restraining orders, civil harassment carries the highest burden of proof. He went on to note that the application for temporary restraint in advance of the hearing was a lower standard and that he had already denied that. He essentially sent her the message right off the bat that she’ll need to provide something new and very compelling.

…He also did note that he was unaware that Animal Control had acted on the matter even before she had filed the petition, and that he learned of that from my response (not a great way to begin, dear neighbor).

She was then given the opportunity to provide additional information, which amounted to a blog post I had written shortly after being served, that I had emailed her, and that I had called her on the phone last week.

  1. Yep, I wrote an awful blog post. An emotional rant. Some of you read it. I took it down the next early morning on various grounds. Normally, I reserve my personally-directed vitriol for comment sections. When I do use awful language to judge or rant, there needs to be either some tongue-in-cheek or humorous element or righteous indignation that’s far more widely applicable than just my personal beef with someone.
  2. I emailed her, basically, ‘hey neighbor, let’s have a calm conversation and see if we can find a solution. My primary concern is for all the dogs, so supervised socializing is a high priority.’ Received no response.
  3. I called her last week, lasted 10 seconds. “Neighbor, can you tell me why Moo is in my front yard and my dogs are going crazy?” “Oh, sorry, I’ll call her back over.”

I presented a couple of new pieces myself. First, since she made such a big deal about my Facebook posts, none of which threatened or wished harm to them or their dogs, she has one talking about a bear on her front porch digging through their trash, lamenting that it wasn’t on my front porch eating my dogs.

She also made a big deal, from Facebook and blog posts, that I have guns, this makes her uncomfortable, etc. So, I was able to present a photo from her dad’s Facebook page of her shooting a handgun at a gun range.

The judged excused himself for 10 minutes to go backstage and read all the new material, saying he’d be ready to rule shortly after returning.

Upon his return, he asked the petitioner if she had anything else at all. She said yes, but really just reiterated stuff, as if trying one last time to pull off a Hail Mary.

But before he ruled, he did take time to, I think primarily, show her why, even though my deleted blog post was as awful as it was, using terms associated with sexism and misogyny, it was part factual, part emotional, but is protected speech, since it contained no express or implied threat to her.

He also interjected to me that I’m a good writer that had obviously spent a lot of time developing my style and in his opinion, that type of emotional vitriol is beneath that skill level. Kinda cool; a nice dispensation from the bench. I didn’t argue, even though I might have drawn a couple of distinctions. For example, using terms associated with sexism and misogyny against an individual does not mean you believe they apply to all individuals of that gender. But of course, longtime readers know that I get this all the time.

…Very ironically, I’ve paid for demographics of my blog traffic a number of times over the years and always, the top category is: “females over 25 with college or higher.” Ha!

So, the decision, as you’ve guessed by now: Petition Denied.

She asked if she could ask a question, and the judge said OK, but he can’t offer legal advice. She asked how she could stop me from posting about her on the Internet. She got a lesson in the 1st Amendment, drawing on the precise essential element of it: it’s there to protect speech people don’t like.

And that’s the whole story and nothing but the story.

…On the way home, Beatrice opined that it’s a good thing the standard of proof is so high; otherwise, there would be millions of restraining orders, including almost all the kids in her junior high. LOL.

Had they only been more neighborly when we initially reached out? It’s cool to have young folk around. I’d rather have taught them lessons in a much friendlier way.

Here’s a friendly one, and they can have a laugh, too.

In closing, I would encourage that any comments match my style, above.

I’ve already done all the venting and name-calling that’s “necessary” and there are a couple of rather distinct things about how I operate.

First, I go off with awful bluster because it often scares people off and if they’re too scared to waste my time with even more bullshit, it’s fine with me. Second, it intimidates and if you’re too intimidated to take me on, that’s a time-saver for me and I don’t give a shit that you feel slighted. Third, and most importantly—the thing so many miss—is that you know I’m not lying to you, blowing smoke rings up your ass.

Think about that. If I’m willing to essentially embarrass myself with awful, socially unacceptable vitriol, what are the chances I’m holding back anything material?

All that outlined, the one thing I am not and am essentially incapable of is going out of my way in vindication. I can’t hold a grudge. I can’t. It has always been out of reach for me and it’s perhaps my favorite quality about myself that I consider redeeming. Life is too short to stew over.

I’m a damn sucker for redemption, too.


WHAT IT'S ABOUT AND HOW IT WORKS

Free The Animal is an eclectic writing project about everything since November 2003. 23 years, 5,500 posts, 5 million words.

It's a paid membership blog. Most posts are free and public, but only paid members can comment. What determines whether it's free or paid is when I publish. Monday through Friday, free and public. Saturday and Sunday, for paid members. That's it. Membership info here.

28 Comments

  1. BabyGirl on April 14, 2017 at 18:57

    “females over 25 with college or higher.”

    That’s me.

    “I’m a damn sucker for redemption, too.”

    And here it is Good Friday.

    Very well written. Sorry you’re having neighbor problems.



    • Natalie on April 14, 2017 at 19:40

      25 for 11 years now, MS :)
      Nice to know there’re still some decent judges around here.



    • Michelle on April 14, 2017 at 19:41

      Another female over 25, college. I’m sorry to hear about it as well. I try to cultivate a pleasant attitude as in general women around my age and younger are a toxic mess. As soon as I saw the headline on the first post I knew it would be a woman. It’s always the women, often backed up by a dumb ass white knight man. Again, I am sorry to hear about your neighbor thing and happy that your pups are well.



  2. Tom Murin on April 14, 2017 at 22:12

    Over 50 male with college. Your neighbor thinks you’re the crazy one. No amount of fact or logic would ever change her mind. She’s a “victim.”



    • Richard Nikoley on April 14, 2017 at 22:22

      Ah, we’ll see.

      It would a lot of hands with a full set of fingers to delineate all the lessons I’ve learned in the 32 years since I was 24, living in a beach house in Hayama, Japan.



  3. Ron on April 15, 2017 at 05:10

    Well written Richard, shows a lot of class on your part. I too have been guilty of an initial rant over a situation, then moving on and wondering why people can’t let it go. Don’t mess with my woman, my kids, or my dogs. I would venture a guess that this will end well with your neighbor, and dogs being dogs, will work it out.



  4. Hap on April 15, 2017 at 09:32

    Perhaps you could interest this judge to engage in a college speaking tour to explain the First Amendment?

    If not that, how about the local high school.



    • Richard Nikoley on April 15, 2017 at 09:49

      Well, they’d have to set up safe spaces outfitted with Kool-Aid, coloring books, blankets, and puppies to pet.



  5. ChocoTaco369 on April 15, 2017 at 12:11

    Oh Richard, drama follows you!



    • Richard Nikoley on April 17, 2017 at 09:50

      What’s your point, Chaco, that I don’t eat ass like you do? ;)



  6. Justin Watts on April 15, 2017 at 13:56

    Seems like these days a lot of people don’t know how to be neighborly anymore. Most people on my street keep to themselves and act like a knock on their door is from someone who wants to rape them. They open the door a fraction and button up the conversation as quickly as possible. I make it a point to talk to the houses around me, and I let the kids from them run across the street uninvited to play with my kids in the front yard, or vise versa.

    I stayed in Armenia for a bit, and those people seem to me to have a better understanding of how to interact with those around them. People around you at a store or restaurant would just strike up a conversation, maybe a short one, or it might lead to an invitation for tea or dinner at their house. So you’d go and visit for a bit, and next thing you know an impromptu party would spring up and you’re meeting all kinds of people and eating, drinking, etc. Happened to me more times than I can count.



    • Richard Nikoley on April 15, 2017 at 13:59


    • Justin Watts on April 15, 2017 at 19:21

      Ha. So true. Although after what I wrote earlier, I will admit to being a little more careful these days about who knocks on the door. My neighborhood is good but we have transient folks who walk through from time to time. We once had someone walk in our back door and went through our kitchen drawers while we were upstairs. My brother heard it and came down with a pistol and scared the guy shitless.

      That video really was spot on about how it was for me growing up. When someone visited it was a big deal. We had round blue metal tins with various cookies from England or someplace, and Mom would put them out with coffee and tea when people came over. If it was winter Mom would make hot chocolate for the kids. Whoever came over usually wound up staying late, and we were allowed to stay up and be a part of it. I have some really good memories of that. I have made sure my kids have gotten to do that as well.



  7. K9 on April 15, 2017 at 21:50

    That photo of the 3 doggies at your feet is delightful. For some reason I imagine them listening intently as you enlighten them with the whole saga of the unsociable next door neighbors in a warm fatherly voice. All the while you gently stuff your corn pipe and sniff your whiskey as the fire rages in the background. Each time you pause, the doggies would lean forward as if to beg you to continue with your tale.



    • thhq on April 16, 2017 at 09:18

      Those terriers aren’t begging for a story. They want some rats!
      m.youtube.com/watch?v=etKfmx_n6ho
      Or whatever you happen to be eating. Even sweet potatoes.



    • thhq on April 16, 2017 at 15:55

      Our daughter’s Jack Russell is always rehearsing for rodents. Stuffed toys and dog beds get torn to shreds. All the squirrels would be dead if she could climb trees. And she’s a robot vacuum for anything foodlike that falls on the floor.



    • Richard Nikoley on April 16, 2017 at 16:50

      Yep, that’s why they’re better for rodent control than cats. So long as it can’t run up a tree of get under or between something, they’ll get it, shake it to death, and look up for another and another.

      They don’t see them as food, but something to kill.

      They have no right to exist.



  8. Hap on April 17, 2017 at 07:43

    We even have bichon that exhibits behaviors of its ratter heritage…..otherwise a princess.:)



  9. ramon on April 17, 2017 at 09:40

    Apprently one of them watches one of those TV courts or has a friend that dabbled in law school before quitting/ failing and got the bright idea to “stick it to him in court…man”.

    ridiculous. neighbor issues do suck especially the “entitled ones”.



    • Richard Nikoley on April 17, 2017 at 12:26

      Not necessarily.

      What happened is they called the sheriff, probably embellished the turn of events the night before, and importantly, omitted the simple fact that it was my reaction to their reaction of me going through due process right down the line.

      That’s why I told the sheriff to fuck off. He was operating on lies, not conducting a proper investigation.

      He called them back saying the convo didn’t go well, and advised them to file the restraining order (this is actually delineate in the narrative of her complaint).



    • ramon on April 17, 2017 at 12:41

      So the lazy sherriff caused all this heartache and wasted the court’s and your time. Glad you told him to f off. You are way better at doing that and coming out a victor than I am.



  10. Hap on April 18, 2017 at 08:46

    If you had your hearing 100 miles due west……you’d be in prison. Guaranteed.

    Stick around in Arnold.



  11. John on April 18, 2017 at 09:45

    To stop your writing:

    Your neighbor could research defamation and libel law. Then get frustrated at the necessary proof. Then say “dammit something being true is a defense.”



    • Richard Nikoley on April 18, 2017 at 11:15

      Oh, I’d love her to chomp on that bit.

      That would give me another two years of entertainment, and I’d do it pro se, just like this.

      But I’d financially devastate her and her father in the process.



  12. Amy on April 20, 2017 at 16:12

    Poor Miss Nuke. I hate to see punctures like that on an old little girlfriend. :(

    Also, it’s obvious that your neighbor is a lying-ass little slag. I’ve dealt with a couple of those in my time. Hopefully they’ll move after this. The best thing about renters is they’re usually transient.

    That said, you’re not going to like this. But as a large dog owner, I need to say it.

    People with little dogs often see no need to control them, as they don’t see the little dogs as a threat to anyone. Yap, yap, yap and the little dogs go charging off. “Awwwwww. Aren’t they cute???? Don’t worry, they don’t mean any harm!!”

    I wish I had a dollar for every baleful look or curse word that’s been thrown my way because I yelled at a little dog owner who couldn’t control their little dogs off leash. I’d be rich.

    Owners of little dogs simply do not seem to get that it’s not the little dogs biting my big dogs that I’m worried about when I yell at them. They don’t seem to get that their dogs are not what they need to be worrying about, either.

    NO…what I’m worried about, and what every small dog owner needs to be worried about and doesn’t seem to be, is the fact that their dogs have bad manners and will *provoke* one of my otherwise well-behaved big dogs into an attack.

    My dogs are voiced trained and when off leash will not run up to anyone else’s dogs, ever. But if some yappy little dog runs up to us and thinks they’re gonna throw down with my dog, it won’t end well. Thankfully I’ve always been on top of it to intervene, so no punctures have ever happened. But if I had a dollar for every time something like this *almost* happened to me, I’d be rich.

    And again, if I had a dollar for every ounce of ire I’ve earned from the dumb-ass owner of a yappy small dog because of my truthful observations on their behavior and that of their dogs, I’d be rich cuz of that, too.

    Bottom line: if you know your dogs will not behave off leash, and that they engage in provocative behavior like that, it’s on you, as the human that allows them to behave that way, that your dog got bit. If you can’t control them and keep them confined to your own property then you have no business letting them out like that.

    You’ve always seemed kind of proud of that pugnacious behavior in your dogs. But the human equivalent of that yappy, in-your-face barking at other dogs would be me running up to you and everyone else on the street and yelling “FUCK YOU ASSHOLE FUCK YOU ASSHOLE FUCK YOU ASSHOLE FUCK YOU ASSHOLE FUCK YOU!!!!!!!”

    How well would that go over, hmmm? Think if I did that someone might hurt me?

    And if you think a human would be provoked into hurting me, why would you expect a *dog* to behave any differently towards another dog, under the exact same provocation?

    People with large dogs can’t let their dogs perpetrate that kind of behavior because everyone in the universe would call Animal Control on them in a heartbeat. It boggles my mind every fucking day why small dog owners think it’s okay just because the dogs are small. And yet, they do, and so shit like this goes on all day, every day.

    Truth is, that regardless of whether anyone else’s dogs are off leash or not, you shouldn’t let yours behave that way. It’s not cute, it’s not precious, it’s BAD MANNERS. And obviously, it’s dangerous. If you can’t stop it then don’t let them out places where it will get them into trouble, or at least take the trouble to make sure the coast is clear before you let them out, and then exert yourself to stay with them. You talk about a standard of reasonable control (which you mentioned as a reason for your call to Animal Services) that your neighbor didn’t have, when truth is you have no more control (and possibly less) than your bum-ass neighbor.

    And then you reported your neighbor’s dog *to the fucking government* for something that was essentially YOUR FAULT!!! OMG! Unless I’m missing critical information, that report to Animal Servicw sounds like the tit-for-tat reason this whole court drama got started. You knew that dog didn’t have rabies, and if that’s your ostensible reason for making the call then you’re being disingenuous.

    No, all you had to do was reconcile yourself to your own culpability in this situation and the whole court drama could have been avoided. But nope. Even when you’re at fault, you always try to make it seem like you’re not. Or you were at fault but you were provoked or there are extenuating circumstances so it’s really all THEIR fault.

    And yes, yes. I know. I need to Go Fuck Myself. I’m a Cunt. I’m a Man-Hating She-Cow. Am I forgetting some manner of epithet here? Blah blah blah. Take a chill pill, Richard. Go dig out your stash of meds if they’ll help you control your vitriol. Trust me, I give two shits less about your vitriol than you say you give about anyone else’s opinion. You love to dish out truth but one thing I’ve noticed is that when someone dishes it to you, you don’t always take it well.

    You need to re-think your shit in this instance, Richard. I doubt you will, and ban me if you want. I don’t want to fight with you, and honestly, I think your little dogs are cute and bright as little sweet buttons. But what I’m saying here is the fucking truth, and what I’m seeing in this post is that you don’t quite seem to get it. You think cuz you won that all is right with the world. But this drama was primarily your fault, for the reasons outlined. Your sweet dog got bit because you indulged her bad manners instead of teaching her better or keeping her away from danger. I just hope you see that and you’ll change things accordingly in the future.



    • Richard Nikoley on April 20, 2017 at 17:38

      Dude, you go on and on and on.

      Yawn. A bid dog diatribe. I grew up with nothing but big black labs.

      It’s my fucking property. They aren’t on others’, and only minimally in the street.

      That said, we take them hiking all the damn time to off leash places. And they are perfect. So that’s what we do when we can and we always seek out off leash.

      Dogs are almost uniformly cordial and fabulous when they don’t have humans fucking with their zen.



  13. Amy on April 20, 2017 at 18:18

    Dude, this wasn’t a “big dog diatribe” and you know it. I’m forced to conclude you’re being deliberately obtuse. Probably because I’m right and you don’t want to admit it.

    Over the years you’ve said many times how your dogs are territorial and even in this post you seemed proud of the fact that they went yap-yap-yapping up to your neighbor’s fence even when the neighbor dogs weren’t out. To quote you, your dogs’ motivation is “because others have no right to exist”. Awwwwwwww. How cute!!!

    Gotta wonder how cute you would think it was if your neighbor’s big dogs behaved similarly, for the same reason, though. How entertaining is it when a 70lb dog doesn’t think other dogs have a right to exist? How funny is it when an owner indulges that behavior in a 70lb dog?

    The point being, just because your dogs are small does not make it any more acceptable.

    Or, if you want an analogy you can really relate to: bad behavior in a 5’1″, 100lb woman is just as unattractive as the same behavior in a 6’1″ 200lb man…right? Just because the woman is small doesn’t make it any more acceptable…right?

    You seem to be deliberately missing the point that this whole affair was YOUR FAULT for indulging that type of obnoxious territorial behavior in your otherwise lovely dogs. If you keep missing the point this might happen again.

    As you like to say, I don’t give a runny shit about whether or not some asshole hauls you to court. I’m posting all this because I love dogs and I’m primarily concerned about your beautiful dogs getting hurt again because you’re too myopic to see a crucial point where you’re coming up short as a pack leader. Holding them to disciplined standards of behavior isn’t cruelty, it’s love.

    I’ve almost posted something less diatribe-y in the past, when you seemed prideful of your little dogs’ provocative behavior, but decided against it because the facts weren’t explicit and I realized I might be missing something. Now, though, it’s clear that your dog got hurt because of your myopia and your wrong-headed indulgence and pride. Just please get over it and stop letting them behave that way. It’s not cute and you *can* stop it. If you will.



    • Richard Nikoley on April 20, 2017 at 18:54

      Amy,

      In how many ways do you need a signal that this dude doesn’t find what you think you “think” particularly compelling?

      You’re bordering on wife territory and she’ll tell you I shut down early with this sort of incessant female balderdash.

      I don’t know what else to tell you, Amy. I really don’t give a shit what you think, nor your silly adminitions for me.

      Talk to me like you’re talking to a man, maybe?

      I am a sucker for pithy.